FREE DOMESTIC SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $75

Pin of the Month

Mythical's Pin of the Month is a collector's dream, featuring a new limited edition pin available every month! Grab yours now before it's gone!

Our Pin of the Month program is done as a pre-order, and the product pages will always state the expected shipping date! 

Looking to access your current subscription plan? Click here!

41 Results

Clear filters
Cupid Candy Randy Pin of the Month
Sold out

Cupid Candy Randy Pin of the Month

$14.99

Dink It & Sink It Pin of the Month
Sold out

Dink It & Sink It Pin of the Month

$14.99

Two Chilly Guys Pin of the Month
Sold out

Two Chilly Guys Pin of the Month

$14.99

November 2025 - Turkeytrice Pin of the Month
Sold out

November 2025 - Turkeytrice Pin of the Month

$14.99

Pin of the Month - Monthly Subscription (Starting April)
PRE-ORDER ⏰

Pin of the Month - Monthly Subscription (Starting April)

$14.99

Pin of the Month - Yearly Subscription (Starting April)
PRE-ORDER ⏰

Pin of the Month - Yearly Subscription (Starting April)

$15.00

Pin of the Month with two bats on a branch. Hanging and fanging!
Pin of the Month with two bats: one green perched on a branch, one blue hanging upside down.
Sold out

As You Can See, We Can't Pin of the Month

$14.99

Sunny Side Up Pin of the Month: Pin of a sunny side up egg with two yolks, one with a beard and one with glasses.
Sunny Side Up Pin of the Month: Two men with egg pins on their shirts.
Sold out

Sunny Side Up Pin of the Month

$14.99

Cotton Candy Randy-corn Glitter Enamel Pin of the Month with a unicorn eating pink cotton candy.
Cotton Candy Randy-corn Glitter Enamel Pin of the Month with a unicorn wearing a white beard and a blue cap.
Sold out

Cotton Candy Randy-corn Glitter Enamel Pin of the Month

$14.99

Two Men On A Double Bike Pin of the Month: "I'm On Vacation!" featuring two figures riding a bike.
Two Men On A Double Bike Pin of the Month, showing two men riding a yellow double bike pin.
Sold out

Two Men On A Double Bike Pin of the Month

$14.99

Cartographer Chase Flying Dart Pin of the Month with figure holding his hat on world map background.
Cartographer Chase Flying Dart Pin of the Month with a cartoon man in a safari hat and a red dart.
Sold out

Cartographer Chase Flying Dart Pin of the Month

$14.99

Floral Randler pin of the month, features a floral deer with a golden trim and wings, and tail made of purple flowers.
Floral Randler Pin of the Month pin. The pin is gold-plated with a colorful floral design.
Sold out

Floral Randler Pin of the Month

$14.99

Wizard pin of the month with Rhett the bean wizard with a staff and red hat.
Rhett the Bean Wizard Pin of the Month: Pin of Rhett the Bean Wizard.
Sold out

Rhett the Bean Wizard Pin of the Month

$14.99

Close-up of the Link the Serpent King Pin of the Month.
Link the Serpent King pin of the month featuring an animated snake and king with a sword.
Sold out

Link the Serpent King Pin of the Month

$14.99

Stink Make Me Horny Locket Pin of the Month. Heart-shaped locket pin with a flame inside of a smaller heart.
Stink Make Me Horny Locket Pin of the Month: Open heart locket pin with "Stink make me horny" text inside.
Sold out

Stink Make Me Horny Locket Pin of the Month

$14.99

Two Rhett & Link blindfold mini pins of the month. One is a sleep mask, the other has black glasses.
Pins of the Month: Rhett and Link wearing blindfold mini pins on an orange jacket.
Sold out

Rhett & Link Blindfold Mini Pins of the Month

$14.99

Pin of the Month. Angled view of the Cotton Candy Randy pin, carrying a red sack, pink beard, green eyebrows and blue sleep cap.
Pin of the Month: Cotton Candy Randy pin! Santa-like character with a blue hat and a red gift bag.
Sold out

DEC 2024 - CCR Claus Pin of the Month

$14.99

Close-up of Mythical's Pin of the Month, a limited edition collector's pin.
Pin of the Month: Mushroom pin featuring 2 smiling mushroom figures on a log.
SOCIETY EXCLUSIVE 🔒

NOV 2024 - Two Fungis Pin of the Month

$14.99

Spooky GMM Desk Pin of the Month with two ghosts, one with glasses, behind a coffin with a candle on top, over a blue glitter background.
Spooky GMM Desk Pin of the Month with two ghosts, a table, and a candle.
Sold out

OCT 2024 - Spooky GMM Desk Pin of the Month

$14.99

Carousel of Characters Pin of the Month featuring a building exterior with Cotton Candy Randy standing inside.
Carousel of Characters pin with Cotton Candy Randy peering from a purple doorway behind yellow planks, under pink windows.
SOCIETY EXCLUSIVE 🔒

SEPT 2024 - Carousel of Characters Pin of the Month

$14.99

Let's Talk About That Pin of the Month. Pin with the text "Let's Talk About That!"
Angled view of gold pin with two posts. Let's Talk About That is on the Let's Talk About That Pin of the Month.
SOCIETY EXCLUSIVE 🔒

AUG 2024 - Let's Talk About That Pin of the Month

$14.99

Rhett & Link's Giant Cereal Bowl Bath Pin of the Month with Rhett and Link figures in a cereal bowl.
Angled view of Rhett & Link's Giant Cereal Bowl Bath Pin of the Month with Rhett and Link figures and a bowl of cereal design.
SOCIETY EXCLUSIVE 🔒

JULY 2024 - Rhett & Link's Giant Cereal Bowl Bath Pin of the Month

$14.99

Sliding shuffleboard pin of the month with blue and red dots and orange and yellow colors.
Sliding Shuffleboard Pin of the Month with blue and red balls and white arm.
SOCIETY EXCLUSIVE 🔒

JUNE 2024 - Sliding Shuffleboard Pin of the Month

$14.99

Veloci-Randy pin showing a pink dinosaur with a blue cap and a gap-toothed grin.
Angled view of Veloci-Randy Pin of the Month. Pin shows a silver velociraptor figure.
Sold out

MAY 2024 - Veloci-Randy Pin of the Month

$14.99

Load more